$2,399,900
Garden City
6 bd 3 ba 297 m²
Garden City, New York: Houses and Co-ops on Long Island
64 homes and apartments for sale in Garden City, United States.
Properties for sale in Garden City
24 properties shown
$1,285,000
Garden City
3 bd 1 ba 143 m²
$2,800,000
Garden City
7 bd 3 ba 353 m²
$1,999,000
Garden City
4 bd 3 ba 288 m²
$2,950,000
Garden City
5 bd 4 ba 313 m²
$760,000
Garden City
4 bd 1 ba 171 m²
$1,160,000
Garden City
4 bd 2 ba 146 m²
$2,668,000
Garden City
5 bd 4 ba 323 m²
Apartment$500,000
Garden City
1 bd 1 ba 55 m²
Apartment$689,000
Garden City
2 bd 1 ba 95 m²
$1,199,000
Garden City
3 bd 1 ba 164 m²
$2,698,000
Garden City
5 bd 5 ba 339 m²
Apartment$425,000
Garden City
2 bd 1 ba 60 m²
$1,849,999
Garden City
6 bd 3 ba 339 m²
$2,850,000
Garden City
5 bd 5 ba 316 m²
$6,399,999
Garden City
5 bd 8 ba 1,156 m²
$2,899,000
Garden City
6 bd 5 ba 343 m²
Apartment$2,799,000
Garden City
3 bd 3 ba 171 m²
$1,499,000
Garden City
3 bd 3 ba 194 m²
$799,999
Garden City
3 bd 1 ba 96 m²
$1,749,000
Garden City
3 bd 2 ba 192 m²
$1,299,999
Garden City
3 bd 1 ba 167 m²
$1,295,000
Garden City
5 bd 2 ba 207 m²
$1,279,000
Garden City
3 bd 2 ba 145 m²
Buyer's guide: Garden City
Garden City is a planned village in Nassau County, about 20 miles east of Manhattan, and Garden City real estate is mostly large single-family houses on tree-lined streets. We currently list 64 properties with a median asking price of €1,241,731. The sections below cover the market mix, commuting and the taxes that surprise first-time overseas buyers.
Price table
Asking prices from current listings on RealEstateAbroad, in euros; sold prices may differ.
| Metric | Garden City |
|---|---|
| Listings | 64 |
| Median asking price | €1,241,731 |
| p25 to p75 | €893,081 to €1,854,327 |
| Median price per m² | €6,981 |
| Median size | 184 m² |
Houses lead; some apartments and a plot
There are 51 houses, 12 apartments and 1 piece of land. Bedrooms cluster at the upper end: 20 properties have five or more, 17 have four, 17 have three, 6 have two, and a handful have one or none. The apartment stock is mostly co-ops and condominiums near the centre, which can be a cheaper way into the village.
See all houses in the United States, apartments and land for wider comparison.
| Type | Listings |
|---|---|
| House | 51 |
| Apartment | 12 |
| Land | 1 |
Read more (3 more sections)Show less
Living in Garden City
The village was laid out in the 19th century by the merchant Alexander T. Stewart, with wide streets, a central green and a compact downtown. The Long Island Rail Road runs into Penn Station and Grand Central, and the Roosevelt Field shopping area and Adelphi University are close. Schools in the Garden City district are the main reason many families pay the premium.
The main trade-off is property tax: Nassau County bills are among the highest in the United States, and they can be a larger annual cost than many buyers expect. Ask for the current tax bill on any home you consider.
What overseas buyers should check
New York has no restriction on foreign ownership of homes, but if a co-op is involved a board will vet you and may require large cash reserves or refuse non-resident buyers. Use a New York attorney. Closing costs include a mortgage recording tax if you borrow, title insurance and attorney fees. Purchases of $1 million or more in New York State attract a 1% 'mansion tax' paid by the buyer.
Read the US purchase guide, compare financing routes and use the valuation tool to test a seller's asking price.
Garden City's price per square metre is easy to read; the property tax bill is the number to ask for first.
Neighbouring markets
Valley Stream and Queens Village are the closest listed neighbours, and Little Neck, Bayside and Fresh Meadows lie in Queens further west or north. Great Neck on the North Shore is a separate high-end market, also in Nassau County.
Last updated 8 October 2026
Buying property in Garden City: FAQ
How far is Garden City from Manhattan?
About 20 miles. The LIRR trip to Penn Station is typically around 30 to 40 minutes.
Why are property taxes so high?
Long Island school districts are funded largely by local property tax, so bills are high. Compare actual tax bills, not just asking prices.
Can a foreigner buy a co-op?
Legally yes, but co-op boards approve buyers and may demand large reserves. Condos and houses are easier.
What is the mansion tax?
A 1% New York State charge on residential purchases of $1 million or more, paid by the buyer.
Are there lots or land for sale?
Rarely: only 1 plot among 64 listings, since the village is fully built out.
More property in United States
United States
Popular cities in United States
- New York(4,393)
- Las Vegas(3,865)
- Brooklyn(2,936)
- San Diego(2,076)
- Orlando(1,736)
- Henderson(1,626)
- Naples(1,494)
- Jacksonville(1,491)
- Charlotte(1,485)
- Cape Coral(1,476)
Property types in United States
- Houses for sale(112,359)
- Apartments for sale(40,550)
- Land for sale(5,767)